Just One More Chef Crush

Some posts on this site contain affiliate links, meaning if you book or buy something through one of these links, I may earn a small commission (at no extra cost to you!). Read the full disclosure policy here.

Maui, United States

I know. I know. My chef crush list is getting really long. Last year on Maui I added two chefs, both well deserving. Sheldon went on to star on Top Chef (not surprised) and Isaac continues to inspire with his perfectly balanced food.

So when I arrived this year several people asked if I had met Jeff Scheer from Maui Executive Catering.

Apparently he had been making waves on the island and some think that good looks alone make it to the chef crush list.

They do not.

Sure there are a lot of good looking chefs who think they can cook. But the crush is all about the food so I was adamant about not adding more to my ever growing list just because some of the girls on the island thought he was a catch.

But his food changed my mind.

Jeff is originally from Ohio where he worked as a chef. He is very laid back, particularly for a chef but I can see why he is now on Maui.

He came here ten years ago intending to only spend a few months here but the island is a slippery slope and it captures many people in its swell.

Although he had worked as a chef he attended Maui Culinary Academy to learn from great chefs and while he intended to originally be a private chef the reality wasn’t what he expected.

He was working 80 hours a week and he realized he loved catering.

But what makes Jeff special is that he really does believe in farm to table. So much so that he volunteers one day a week at Kupa’a Farm, the organic farm I visited last week that takes interns.

He aims for 90% of his produce to be from Kupa’a and tonight’s dinner featured 100% from this couple.

He is so committed to this that when he has catering jobs he cannot guarantee what the food will be as it depends on what is available from the farm.

maui executive catering

His food is good. Really good. And because I spend much of my waking hours eating food, cooking food or thinking about food it can be really difficult to surprise me.

But tonight Jeff surprised me.

flank steak

All of the dishes were great but when I first tried the flank steak I thought it was just okay but then was told I needed to eat all of the components together.

The tanginess of the yogurt was a really surprising combination and I can’t stop thinking about it.

He’s won me over. Jeff makes the chef crush list.

Tonight’s dinner was not catering but a private chef’s table in his kitchen. It’s an amazing experience to see someone cook for you and also to see things fail right at the table – like the egg yolks which broke during plating.

To up the ante Jeff chose to make things that he had never served before.

This isn’t just dinner it’s a food experience.

But it isn’t one just for me. Maui Executive Catering offers chef tables to small groups and they are planning much more, including a restaurant next year.

And also I keep thinking about his kitchen. He has an intern who has been working for him before attending the culinary academy and it’s an incredible opportunity.

As I lay thinking about the flank steak and yogurt I keep wondering, would Jeff take on an intern for a month?

Disclosure: I was a guest of the Maui Visitor’s Bureau, they did not request that I write a favourable review or add another chef crush to my list.

Join the Conversation

  1. Foodsnearme says:

    Nice post. Thanks if you are travelling in Indian Highway’s then this will help you. Roadies

  2. I can definitely see why he made it to your growing chef crush list. What a great business…hope it catches on!

  3. I sometimes forget to eat all the flavours together on pretty plates like that. This all looks divine!

  4. I knew him in Ohio, Ohio lost a great chef!!! Mahalo for choosing Maui!

  5. Carolyn Jung says:

    LOL I think you are going to have to duke it out with our Maui host, Charlene, who is gah-gah for Jeff. May the best gal win. 😉


  7. Great profile on an up and coming chef. I worked in F&B service with Four Seasons Lanai for 8 years and am very familiar with local food and the islands. You make me really look forward to my first visit home in 3 years coming up this July!


    Just kidding 🙂 It’s always wonderful to find someone’s got something going on behind a beautiful face.

  9. Federico says:

    It is true that sometimes one forget to eat all the ingredients at once as it usually makes a big difference both in consistency and flavor.

  10. Martine @ Chompchomp says:

    I love his presentation. Who says a way to a mans heart is with food? Its gets into a womans heart too!

  11. I love the way you write about food! I always find it so hard. Love the chef crush series. 🙂

  12. john@discoverydiscovery says:

    great one!if there’s something I like most about going on trips an and travel..it’s foods..different kinds, different taste.

  13. Emily in Chile says:

    I love that people are now making suggestions for chefs they think you should add to your list! Based on the photos and his philosophy, I think Jeff makes a good addition.

    1. Ayngelina Author says:

      I know, I just want them to know that I’m not using the site as a way to land a chef boyfriend 🙂

  14. Maui Goodness says:

    I’m so glad to finally see this post! Yes, Jeff is a culinary master and we’re so fortunate to have him on our island. His Chef’s Table always leaves me feeling incredibly special for having experienced it. A lot of people are happy hearing that they are now doing it 4 times per month. Excellent article, and a well-deserved chef crush!

Comments are closed.

© Copyright 2021. Bacon Is Magic. All rights reserved